Birds of a Feather Archive

Ethics in HPC: With Great Power Comes Great Responsibility


Authors: Jay Lofstead (Sandia National Laboratories, University of New Mexico), Jakob Luettgau (French Institute for Research in Computer Science and Automation (INRIA)), Elaine Raybourn (University of Central Florida)

Abstract: The implications of HPC technology on society and the environment prompt us, as a community, to discuss and understand our direct and indirect impacts. This BoF is highly interactive and aims to facilitate discussion within the community, relating ethical behavior and societal norms to the design of HPC solutions and autonomous/intelligent systems. The BoF will feature breakout groups and then converge to a plenum discussion. By furthering this dialogue, we can ensure that the HPC community advances its commitment to technology for the benefit of humanity as a whole. We do not expect to reach conclusions, but raise ideas.

Long Description: Ethical concerns in science date back centuries. However, the acceleration of innovation and the increasing impact of high-performance computing (HPC) on daily life make these discussions more important than ever. The goal of this BoF is to foster a community-wide discussion about ethics in HPC, addressing issues such as our responsibilities as practitioners and the best ways to ensure ethical considerations in HPC application development and implementation. The BoF will provide a series of ethical principles applied to cases to serve as discussion points.

These points are designed to be broad and somewhat controversial to encourage discussion. For example, one point is "HPC resources are expensive and must be financially supported by the user community to be accessible." This point prompts discussion about whether HPC resources should be shared with the general public or only with those who can afford to field their own resources or buy or rent time on someone else's resources. The economic advantage of access has long been proven, prompting a discussion of what the developed world owes developing countries. Uses such as weather forecasting and storm damage prediction are a matter of life and death; however, resource access is critical for accurate predictions.

Although HPC is a widely applied computational tool, it is ethically neutral. However, some applications can fall into gray areas, such as its use in resource exploration, maintaining nuclear arsenals, or mining personal information for targeted advertising or mass surveillance. Additionally, because HPC promotes open-source software, it can be leveraged for unethical purposes, such as engineering an effective disinformation campaign or designing an optimally destructive pathogen. Because it is a technology that can be abused, we must consider what, if anything, the community should do to prevent this. The rise of AI/ML tools further complicates this discussion, prompting conversations about jobs, energy, and lethal autonomous weapons systems.

This BoF aims to address these issues and determine which values we should promote as a community and the most effective ways to do so. By facilitating discourse among HPC practitioners, we aim to better understand the technology's benefits and challenges, as well as foster detailed, nuanced discussions about the ethics of HPC. Given the difficulty these issues raise, we do not expect to reach consensus. Instead, we want to have fruitful discussion to increase awareness of various perspectives from the always varied background of the attendees.

Each year as we have held this BoF, the audience has consistently engaged offering deep discussion of why we each have the perspectives we do. As others bring up additional perspectives, the conversations adapt to try to encompass the broader views raising awareness for everyone. We cannot reach a consensus with everyone, but seek to have lively discussion to raise everyone's awareness from the broad audience.

Website: https://ethicsinhpc.org



Back to Birds of a Feather Archive Listing